Thursday, August 5, 2010

Posted by smileyface on 5:30 AM
0

Hwa Chong STOMP Article Controversy

The recent STOMP article written about how teachers took away students' belongings has been a source of controversy both on STOMP and among Hwa Chong students. In the article (submitted by an angry secondary 4 student who wished to complain about the school's practices), it is described how teachers took away student's belongings that were left unattended on tables*. I feel that the student was being very inconsiderate by tarnishing the school's reputation. Although it is understandable that he might be angry after he had his personal space invaded and his belongings taken, he should have taken his complaint to the school administration itself rather than making this issue public. The matter could have been resolved quietly and internally instead of what it has become now- a public mess. The STOMP article has attracted many hateful comments toward Hwa Chong students and the school, questioning their "giftedness" if they can make a mistake as simple as leaving their belongings around.


I feel that the school should make clear what happened that day, why they feel their actions were justified, and meet up with the student and his parents to ascertain the reason for the student's unhapiness with the school's actions. According to one of our recent assemblies, not only are some of the details reported in the STOMP article untrue, the students were already informed that they would be punished in such a way should they leave their belongings unattended.

Therefore, I conclude that the student has no right to sabotage the school's reputation for his own petty anger against it, especially seeing as how evidence suggests that the schools actions were justified.

*The same punishment actually happened to our class earlier in the year. Multiple laptops were taken and students were required to retrieve their laptops back from teachers. However, the matter was quickly resolved and the students' general consensus is that they do not mind since no permanent damage was done/no items went missing.

No comments:

Post a Comment